Affected by the global boycott wave triggered by the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, Starbucks has suffered a severe blow in the Malaysian market. According to multiple media reports, nearly 50 Starbucks stores in the country have suspended operations over the past year, and operator Berjaya Food has fallen into losses for four consecutive quarters. Although the brand has repeatedly clarified its position and taken public welfare measures in an attempt to win back consumer trust, the boycott movement has still not subsided, and store sales have been slow to recover. This turmoil not only reflects the profound impact of geopolitics on commercial brands, but also leaves Starbucks' future in the Southeast Asian market full of uncertainty. [more…]

Tim Hortons, a coffee chain long regarded as Canada's national pride, has recently found itself at the center of a public opinion storm over a summer camp vaccination policy. The hashtag #BoycottTimHortons quickly trended on Twitter, sparking widespread criticism and calls for a boycott. A policy requiring staff and campers participating in Tim Hortons Foundation Camps to be fully vaccinated against COVID-19 has become the focus of the controversy. Opponents launched a petition that gathered more than 20,000 signatures in just a few days, while supporters argue the move is intended to protect immunocompromised children. As the incident continues to escalate, Tim Hortons has yet to make a public response. [more…]

Recently, several tea beverage brands—including Heytea, Nayuki, ChaPanda, Good Tea, Mixue Bingcheng, and Shuyi Tealicious—were reported to have jointly adjusted their full-reduction strategies on food delivery platforms. The original full-reduction discounts have been uniformly changed to 1 off 50, 1 off 70, or even canceled outright. Once the news broke, related topics quickly trended on social media, with views exceeding 180 million. Merchants say profits are thin, while netizens question why milk tea, which isn't cheap, still isn't making money. Behind this controversy lie both the pressure of platform commissions and delivery costs, and a reflection of the difficult position of the new tea beverage industry, caught between price cuts and losses. [more…]

Global coffee chain giant Starbucks recently released a scenario-based advertisement in the Indian market with a transgender theme, starring well-known transgender actress Sia, telling a heartwarming story of an Indian couple gradually accepting their child's gender identity transition. Once the advertisement was published, it caused an uproar on local social media, with supporters praising it for conveying an inclusive message, while opponents called for a boycott. Facing polarized public opinion, Starbucks officially responded that the advertisement had "received a good response" in India. Is this brand marketing around gender issues a successful breakthrough or a misstep? This article will walk you through the full picture of the incident and the voices from all sides. [more…]

Since the outbreak of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, American chain brands have faced waves of boycotts in Muslim-majority regions, with Starbucks bearing the brunt. In Malaysia, a Muslim-majority country, local consumers' boycott of Starbucks has led to a sharp drop in foot traffic. The latest financial report from franchise operator Berjaya Food shows that in the first half of this year, its Starbucks business suffered a massive loss of 87.34 million ringgit (approximately 143 million RMB). To reverse the decline, Berjaya Food has repeatedly stated that Starbucks Malaysia is wholly owned by a local listed company, with employees almost entirely local and mostly Muslim, in an attempt to distance itself from the US headquarters. However, the boycott continues, even affecting employees' livelihoods and stock performance. How this situation will unfold and whether Starbucks can regain local consumers' trust is worth watching. [more…]

Recently, Chagee sparked boycotts among netizens in Vietnam and Malaysia successively due to a background image in its app that included the nine-dash line map. Vietnam not only removed the app from its platforms but also dismantled the signboard of the first store in Ho Chi Minh City; after Malaysian netizens discovered the same issue, they too joined the chorus of criticism. Although the brand has deleted the controversial image, the public outcry has not yet subsided. It is worth noting that, unlike brands such as Starbucks, which faced boycotts over the Israeli-Palestinian conflict leading to the closure of numerous stores, Chagee's offline stores in Kuala Lumpur have maintained steady takeout orders. This article will review the sequence of events and their actual impact on the brand's operations. [more…]

Chinese new tea beverage brand Chagee originally planned a high-profile opening of its first store in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam, but on the eve of the launch, a map in its app suspected of showing the "nine-dash line" in the South China Sea sparked a strong backlash from Vietnamese netizens. Tens of thousands flooded its official Facebook page to express anger, the brand's app was removed from both major app platforms, and a tough response from what appeared to be an official account on TikTok poured fuel on the fire. As of now, Chagee has yet to make a formal response. This boycott storm triggered by a map has not only cast a shadow over the brand's overseas expansion but also sounded a warning bell for other Chinese brands planning to enter the Vietnamese market. Front Street Coffee continues to follow international developments in the coffee and tea beverage industry. [more…]

Vitasoy International Holdings' interim results for the 2021/2022 fiscal year show that revenue fell 18.28% year-on-year, while net profit plunged 95%, marking the largest decline in recent years. The core trigger of this storm was the public backlash caused by the July 2021 incident in which an employee attacked police and then hanged himself, leading to large-scale product removals and celebrity contract terminations in the mainland market—a key region accounting for 60% of the company's total revenue. The incident occurred during the summer sales peak, obstructing new product promotion, while competitors seized the opportunity to accelerate penetration. Industry analysts pointed out that in addition to the public relations crisis, Vitasoy's structural weaknesses in the mainland market—over-reliance on the Pearl River Delta and insufficient penetration in the north—were equally fatal. Rising raw material costs and slow packaging updates further dragged down recovery, and it is expected to take at least three years to restore profitability. This article will sort out the sequence of events, market reactions, and future challenges, providing in-depth reference for observers in the coffee and beverage industry. [more…]

In recent years, animal-themed cafes have rapidly expanded around the world, with everything from cats and dogs to owls, meerkats, raccoons, and other wild animals being brought into the shops. However, animal protection organizations point out that these venues often lack effective oversight, and the animals are kept under chronic stress and sleep deprivation, with their physical and mental health seriously affected. In Japan, nearly 100,000 people have signed a petition demanding the closure of cafes featuring owls and other wild animals, and South Korea has announced a total ban on displaying wild animals outside of zoos. Should consumers also reflect: without demand, how can there be a market? [more…]

Recently, a video of a Cotti Coffee employee destroying a standee of former spokesperson Wang Yibo sparked a huge uproar on social media. In the video, the store clerk deliberately cut up the standee's face and posted it with a caption, provoking widespread discontent and a boycott among fans. As the incident continued to escalate, Cotti issued a public statement of apology on February 28, announcing the termination of cooperation with the store involved and its closure, while promising to strengthen training and oversight of the material recycling process. This controversy has brought the issue of material handling standards after the termination of brand endorsement contracts to the forefront, and has once again drawn industry attention to the protection of artists' portrait rights. [more…]

Recently, the Heytea store in Southampton, UK, replaced its menu with an all-English version, sparking strong dissatisfaction among overseas Chinese consumers. The original poster pointed out that after all Chinese product names disappeared, ordering became difficult, and even Chinese employees made mistakes because they were not accustomed to the new menu. Subsequently, netizens discovered that multiple overseas stores in London, New York, Sydney, and other locations had also switched to all-English menus, and the official app also removed the language selection option, instead displaying based on location. Although some people believe this is catering to localization, more people criticize the move for diluting the brand's Chinese symbols and harming the ordering experience of overseas Chinese. Heytea customer service did not respond directly, and some consumers said they might spontaneously boycott it. [more…]

Recently, a Mixue store located in Segambut, Malaysia, came under scrutiny from netizens due to a job advertisement that specified "experienced Malays and Chinese are required," which was accused of being racially discriminatory. As a multi-ethnic nation, Malaysia's main ethnic groups include Malays, Chinese, and Indians. The poster believed that this requirement excluded Indians and other ethnicities, which was unfair. The incident quickly went viral on social media, sparking widespread discussion. Some netizens criticized the brand's inappropriate practice and called for a boycott, while others argued that the controversy stemmed from a misinterpretation of the language proficiency requirement. Notably, Mixue did not directly respond to the controversy but instead released a series of promotional content themed "United as One," showcasing employees of diverse races, seemingly intending to emphasize its inclusiveness. [more…]

Kopi Luwak is considered a luxury in the coffee world, with prices reaching hundreds of dollars per pound, and products priced below 200 yuan in the domestic market are almost never genuine. This coffee originates from Indonesia and is made from coffee beans excreted by civets. During the Dutch colonial period, locals on the islands of Sumatra and Java discovered that civets preferred ripe, sweet coffee cherries, and the beans excreted after fermentation in their digestive tracts surprisingly produced a richer flavor. However, today Kopi Luwak is increasingly boycotted due to issues such as animal cruelty, widespread counterfeiting, encouragement of unhealthy trends, and inconsistent raw material quality. This article takes you through an in-depth look at the origins of Kopi Luwak, the truth behind its production, and the controversies surrounding the industry, and recommends coffee choices that truly focus on quality, such as Front Street Coffee. [more…]

A video filmed at a Tim Hortons location in Brampton, Toronto, Canada, has sparked widespread attention online, racking up 360,000 views in a short period. The footage captures overflowing trash bins and countertops piled with discarded cups and packaging bags, igniting heated discussion among netizens. The poster attributed the problem to the composition of the staff and questioned whether people should continue to patronize the brand. The comment section was quickly flooded with thousands of messages, with some calling for reports to health authorities and others pointing out that this is not an isolated case, as similar conditions exist at multiple Toronto locations. In recent years, Tims has frequently been exposed for unsanitary kitchens and foreign objects found in food, prompting many consumers to switch to other coffee shops or choose to make coffee at home. [more…]

Tea beverage brand Gu Ming recently launched a 9.9 yuan milk tea unlimited drinking promotion, and starting today, it is distributing 500,000 free vouchers at scheduled times through its mini-program, adding momentum to the campaign. However, after a large number of consumers entered the activity page right at 12 o'clock, they encountered long periods of blank screens and crashes in the mini-program, and related topics once topped the trending searches. According to user feedback, the mini-program had already begun lagging a few minutes before the event started, and after 12 o'clock the server went down for nearly half an hour due to a sudden influx of a large number of requests; even repeatedly refreshing or switching to the computer version made it difficult to load. This is not the first time Gu Ming's mini-program has had problems during popular activities. Long-time users said that previous limited-time activities such as buy-one-get-one-free also often encountered interface crashes, and although they reported poor experiences many times, no obvious improvement was seen. [more…]

Recently, Gu Ming launched a "Summer Buy One Get One Free" campaign, with 8 star products participating, originally intended to attract foot traffic and boost revenue. However, after the campaign went live, store orders far exceeded expectations, and back-of-house staff were forced to handle fresh fruit, whip cream, and other prep work under high intensity for long hours. Some worked 15.5 hours straight, and their hands cramped from peeling grapes. The brand's frequent collaborations, takeout wars, and limited-time offers have left the "farm tea workers" complaining endlessly, and also exposed the disconnect between campaign planning and store staffing and process simplification. This article reviews the real situation of this order surge and the voices of employees, while also offering coffee lovers a product perspective from brands such as Front Street Coffee. [more…]

On July 14, Nayuki suddenly announced the removal of its virtual stock membership campaign, sparking widespread attention. The campaign allowed users to earn Nayuki coins through purchases and to buy and sell virtual stocks linked to the real share price, even supporting leveraged trading. Within just hours of launch, it was mired in controversy, with netizens questioning its legality. Industry experts pointed out that Nayuki coins are essentially consumption points and have not yet crossed legal red lines, but the model is aggressive and should not be simply imitated. At the same time, Nayuki's frequent food safety issues have also led consumers to question its marketing strategy. This article will sort out the course of the incident, the legal controversy, and the brand's hidden concerns. [more…]

Bawang Chaji celebrates its seventh anniversary. All stores in Malaysia launched a tear-the-cup lucky draw campaign on the 16th and 17th, with prizes including discount vouchers, branded backpacks, electronic products, perfumes, and lipsticks, attracting a large number of consumers to place orders enthusiastically. However, after the campaign began, order volumes surged at many stores, with some stores having more than a thousand or even over three thousand drinks awaiting preparation, leading to a series of problems such as excessively long waits to pick up orders, the ordering system being unable to cancel orders, and declining product quality. Consumers expressed dissatisfaction one after another, believing that the brand should have anticipated the campaign's popularity in advance and adopted flow-control measures. This article reviews the course of the incident and feedback from all parties, for the reference of coffee and tea beverage enthusiasts. [more…]

During the 40th Teachers' Day, Chagee launched an exclusive campaign called "Honor Teachers with Tea, Enjoy Tea on Us," originally intended to pay tribute to the teaching community and enhance brand goodwill. However, after the campaign was rolled out, it sparked widespread dissatisfaction among teachers: limited-edition cards at many stores were quickly claimed, and some stores did not participate in the campaign at all, causing many teachers to make a wasted trip. This article sorts out the specific rules of the campaign in various regions, teachers' real experiences of claiming the offer, and responses from the brand and store managers, to help you understand the ins and outs of this marketing controversy. [more…]

Manner previously announced a giveaway cup event on Xiaohongshu, and the light purple ceramic cup in the accompanying images quickly captured the hearts of many cup enthusiasts. As usual, new merchandise would land on various platforms within a day or two after the official poster was released, and many fans even checked with stores in advance about stock availability, gearing up for the rush. However, this event has yet to appear, with some people setting alarms for several nights in a row only to come up empty-handed, while store employees also said they had not yet received notice. Is it the weather that has delayed the nationwide launch, or has there been a problem with the brand's communication? This article will reconstruct the course of events and explore the communication shortcomings exposed by Manner during the event delay controversy. [more…]