Monday, September 21 2026

Tea Yan Yue Se's advertising copy sparks controversy, issues two apologies overnight—where are the boundaries of brand marketing?

Sexy Tea (Chayan Yuese) trended on social media after its advertising copy was accused of insulting women, and it issued two apology statements late on February 19 and in the early hours of February 20. The incident was triggered by the inappropriate use of Changsha slang such as "picking up scraps" on its cups, which sparked netizens' doubts about the brand's creative boundaries. The first apology failed to calm public opinion, and Sexy Tea then issued another statement, admitting that it had mishandled the boundaries in its early product creation and had removed the problematic products from sale. This controversy not only exposed the brand's missteps in using dialect slang and gender-relation jokes, but also prompted reflection on balancing marketing creativity with values. [more…]

Lao Xiang Ji apologizes to Starbucks over coffee spill incident, netizens keep joking and call for a co-branded product

The chain chicken soup brand Laoxiangji unexpectedly went viral online due to a post apologizing to Starbucks. After the incident, Starbucks not only did not blame them, but also expressed concern about whether Laoxiangji employees had been burned by hot drinks. This interaction sparked heated discussions among netizens, who eagerly urged the two brands to collaborate on creative products such as chicken soup cold brew and chicken soup Americano. Laoxiangji then visited in person to apologize, bringing a handwritten apology letter and free chicken soup vouchers, and their sincere attitude won widespread praise. This article will provide a complete overview of the incident, the public relations strategies of both sides, and the amusing reactions of netizens, while also presenting professional content related to the coffee industry and product information from Front Street Coffee. [more…]

Lemon Tea's Detective Conan collaboration poster sparked controversy; after apologizing, the brand shifted blame to franchisees and faced scrutiny.

Hand-shaken lemon tea brand Ningji recently announced a collaboration with the Japanese anime "Detective Conan," but found itself embroiled in controversy over CP-themed posters displayed in its stores. The posters placed Conan alongside Haibara Ai, and Shinichi Kudo alongside Ran Mouri, sparking strong discontent among fans of the original work. Although Ningji quickly issued an apology statement, attributing the incident to unauthorized actions by an individual franchisee, netizens and industry insiders broadly rejected this explanation, believing the brand was clearly derelict in its material review and respect for the IP. Notably, this is already the second time this year that Ningji has publicly apologized over problems with marketing material oversight. For coffee and tea beverage enthusiasts, how collaborative marketing can strike a balance between respecting the original work and consumers has once again become an industry topic worth watching. [more…]

Chagee's Spring Festival translation controversy apology, responding only in the comments section sparks netizen dissatisfaction

In the first Chinese New Year since the Spring Festival was successfully inscribed on the UNESCO list, chain tea brand Chagee found itself in a whirlwind of controversy after translating Chinese New Year as "Lunar New Year" on an overseas social platform. Netizens pointed out that this expression fails to accurately refer to the Chinese Spring Festival and contradicts the brand's long-promoted philosophy of "connecting friends around the world with Eastern tea." Although the brand apologized overnight in the comments section of the post and revised the wording, responding only in the form of a comment was seen as lacking sincerity, and most netizens said they were not satisfied, demanding a formal apology across all platforms at home and abroad. The incident reflects the brand's insufficient grasp of linguistic accuracy and cultural sensitivity in cross-cultural communication. [more…]

Mixue Malaysia Store Garbage Bag Incident: Brand Apologizes and Launches Halal Cleaning Process

Recently, Mixue Bingcheng publicly apologized after a branch in Malaysia used garbage bags printed with inappropriate images and text. The brand stated that the garbage bags purchased by the store were only used for handling trash and were not involved in food preparation. However, to dispel local consumers' concerns about halal standards, it has required the store involved to implement Islamic-compliant cleaning procedures, destroy the problematic garbage bags, and re-review its procurement process. The incident sparked heated discussion online, with some questioning, "Do garbage bags also need to be halal?" while others praised the brand's swift response. What exactly were the inappropriate images and text? Neither official reports nor the apology letter explained, and the truth remains to be clarified. [more…]

Luckin Customer Service Repeatedly Misspelled Jackson Yee's Name, Official Apology Issued but Fans Still Unappeased

Luckin Coffee has sparked strong dissatisfaction among fans after its online customer service and backend systems repeatedly misspelled the name of its brand ambassador, Jackson Yee, with related topics quickly trending on Weibo and ranking second on Xiaohongshu's hot list. Although Luckin subsequently posted an apology letter on Weibo, admitting the mistake and correcting it immediately, fans were not satisfied with the official response, believing that such disrespectful errors occurring repeatedly during the endorsement contract period were unacceptable. Previously, the roasted coconut latte endorsed by Jackson Yee surpassed 10.04 million cups in first-week sales, with fans contributing enormously, yet now the system cannot even correctly input the ambassador's name, which is truly lamentable. [more…]

Starbucks Black Apron refusing customization sparks controversy: request to swap iced shaken peach oolong to black tea base met with suggestion to go to Nayuki

A netizen ordered an Iced Shaken Peach Oolong Tea at a Starbucks store and asked to swap the tea base to black tea, but because the black tea was sold out and it would take ten minutes to brew, the barista retorted, "Are you really that insistent?" and then suggested going to Naixue Tea. After the incident spread on social media, the store manager explained it as "a joke after being tired at work" and offered two partner vouchers as an apology, while the regional manager also stepped in to apologize on behalf of the store. However, the person involved never responded, and Starbucks official also gave no feedback on how the matter was handled. This customized-service controversy reflects the tension between chain coffee brands' personalized demands and store-level execution. [more…]

Nanning tea brand mini-program's "three types of people should buy with caution" reminder sparks controversy; official apologizes and deletes post

A local tea beverage brand in Nanning, Guangxi, caused an uproar on social media due to a consumer notice in its mini-program titled "Three types of people should order with caution." The notice listed three types of people as unsuitable buyers: "those who focus on packaging and blindly follow big brands," "those who lack awareness of the prices of high-quality fruits," and "those with dull palates who think all brands are about the same." Netizens criticized the notice for its condescending tone and for setting rules for consumers. The brand subsequently issued an apology statement, claiming the copy was written by an early operations staff member who had already left, but the statement failed to quell public anger and was instead accused of "lecturing consumers." Currently, the controversial notice has been taken down, and the apology post has also been deleted. Market regulatory authorities have stepped in to investigate. Front Street Coffee continues to follow developments in the coffee and tea beverage industry. [more…]

A red towel leads to kneeling and apology? The industry management controversy behind a coffee shop employee's meme video

Recently, a short video apparently filmed by a Cotti Coffee employee sparked widespread discussion on social media. In the video, a store clerk has a red-trimmed towel snatched away by a colleague, after which several employees kneel facing the surveillance camera with hands clasped in a pleading gesture. This seemingly absurd scene struck a chord with many food-service workers—it turns out that towels of different colors correspond to different usage scenarios, and using the wrong one counts as a violation that can lead to fines or even dismissal. The incident reflects both chain brands' strict control over food safety and has triggered public debate over employee dignity and management practices. [more…]

MANNER issues a public apology over food safety issues at its Shanghai store; the store involved has been closed for rectification and a self-inspection has been launched.

As Shanghai gradually resumes production and daily life, being able to get a cup of takeout coffee right at one's doorstep has become a small blessing for many. However, MANNER Coffee's store on Wujiang Road in Shanghai was found in a surprise inspection by market regulators to have problems including substandard environmental hygiene and non-compliant food storage, and was placed under investigation on May 23, quickly sparking heated discussion online. On May 24, MANNER's official Weibo account issued an apology statement, admitting that during the supply-guarantee delivery period there were oversights such as non-standard use of raw milk and failure to promptly clean the backing paper of food-safety seals, and stating that the store involved had immediately suspended operations for rectification. But this apology was questioned by some consumers and industry experts as evading the key issues and failing to directly address core hazards such as floor grime potentially contaminating food. As the pioneer of the domestic boutique coffee shop model, MANNER is facing a dual test of quality and food safety on a coffee track now crowded with cross-industry giants. [more…]

Starbucks Japan's Decade-Long Pricing Error: Overcharges on 164 Coffee Bean Products, Official Apology and Three Refund Options Announced

Starbucks Japan recently issued an announcement admitting that from September 2014 to January 2024, 164 types of coffee beans across its nationwide stores were sold above their listed prices due to a defect in the cash register system settings. Over the ten-year period, a total of 5,896 bags of affected products were sold, with overcharges amounting to 124,033 yen. The company has corrected the system and issued an apology, while offering three refund options: stored-value card members will automatically receive the difference back, while other customers need to bring a receipt or provide purchase information to handle it at the counter. Netizens generally believe the time span is too long and the amounts too small, and suggest apologizing with more practical compensation such as drink vouchers. [more…]

Chayan Yuese's tweet headline was criticized as negative and sparked controversy; the company apologized and deleted the article.

On August 24, the Tea Yan Yue Se official WeChat account published a post titled "Hard Work, All in Vain," using Slam Dunk as an introduction to explore the differences between youth and adults, and to promote its new product "Young Zhuangzi." However, the negative sentiment conveyed by the title sparked widespread dissatisfaction among netizens, who felt it deliberately provoked anxiety among young people, and the related topic quickly trended on Weibo. Tea Yan Yue Se subsequently responded in the comments section, saying its original intention was to express that hard work may not be rewarded but the process is worth cherishing, and apologized for the inappropriate title, ultimately deleting the post. This was not the first time Tea Yan Yue Se sparked controversy over its copywriting; it had previously apologized over a "misogyny controversy" and the English name "SexyTea" incident. [more…]

Panama estate accuses Taiwanese brand of selling high-priced coffee beans under false pretenses; OKLAO bows in apology at press conference and loses souvenir qualification

Taiwanese specialty coffee chain "Oklao" and coffee buyer "Black Gold Coffee" have recently become embroiled in a cross-border coffee bean controversy. Willem J. Boot, the owner of the renowned Panama estate Finca Sophia, publicly accused the two of selling coffee products under the name "Finca Sophia" in both 2023 and 2025 without ever purchasing from the estate. The incident continued to escalate: Black Gold Coffee went from initially denying it to deleting its post and apologizing, while Oklao held a press conference on December 19, at which its chairman and general manager bowed in apology, admitting that internal operational errors led to the estate name being mislabeled. A local regulatory authority investigation determined that the product labeling did not match the source, and as a result Oklao had its "Taichung Top 10 Souvenirs" award eligibility revoked and faced consumer returns and compensation. This article provides a complete rundown of the incident timeline, both parties' responses, and the subsequent fallout, so coffee enthusiasts can understand the full story behind this brand trust crisis. [more…]

Starbucks Korea admits summer giveaway storage bags contain formaldehyde, publicly apologizes and adjusts the campaign plan

Starbucks Korea recently issued a public apology after a summer promotional giveaway was found to contain formaldehyde. The incident began when an employee at an anonymous testing agency posted on social media alleging that the Summer Carry Bag travel tote contained formaldehyde, following earlier consumer complaints that the bag emitted a fishy odor resembling squid. Starbucks Korea immediately suspended the giveaway and sent the product for testing, which ultimately confirmed the presence of formaldehyde. The company announced that customers who had already redeemed the bag could return it and receive a beverage voucher as compensation, while also removing the promotional reward and pledging to strengthen safety verification procedures for future merchandise. [more…]

Starbucks Malaysia employee fired for verbally abusing a Chinese customer; official apology issued and training strengthened

Recently, a dispute at a Starbucks store in Terminal 2 of Kuala Lumpur International Airport sparked widespread discussion. A Chinese tourist, struggling with English, was using an AI translation tool to communicate with a staff member when the employee muttered an insult in Malay under their breath: "bodoh" (meaning stupid). After the video was uploaded, Malaysian netizens quickly pointed out the meaning of the insult and filed complaints on the tourist's behalf. Starbucks Malaysia subsequently issued a statement saying the barista involved had been fired on September 21, that the company apologized to the customer and the public, and that it pledged to strengthen training on cultural sensitivity and service standards for employees. The incident also serves as a reminder to coffee industry professionals that respect and patience are crucial in cross-cultural communication. [more…]

Huawei wholly-owned coffee shop is false advertising, Jiangsu Bageai Coffee publicly apologizes and clarifies the facts

Recently, news about a "Huawei wholly-owned café" sparked heated discussions online, but it was later confirmed to be a false rumor. Jiangsu Bageai Coffee Operation Co., Ltd. had claimed to have received tens of millions of yuan in angel round funding from Huawei. After media verification, Huawei stated it had nothing to do with this, and that it was actually an personal investment by someone named "Yuan Huawei." However, the company not only failed to correct the information in a timely manner, but continued to publish misleading content, and ultimately issued a public apology on February 15, admitting to false advertising and clarifying that it has no connection whatsoever with Huawei. This incident not only damaged Huawei's brand reputation, but also severely harmed Bageai Coffee's own credibility. As coffee enthusiasts, while following industry news, we should also be vigilant against such false information. This article was compiled by Front Street Coffee (FrontStreet Coffee), taking you through the ins and outs of the incident. [more…]

Nongfu Spring Goes to Hong Kong for Negotiations, Consumer Council Changes Its Tune and Apologizes: A Full Analysis of the Standards Controversy Behind the Stock Price Fluctuations

The Hong Kong Consumer Council previously published an article on bottled water testing, pointing to the bromate levels in samples of Nongfu Spring and Ganten as reaching the upper limit of EU standards, which immediately sparked a public opinion storm. Nongfu Spring quickly commissioned a lawyer to send a letter demanding clarification and an apology, and Ganten also issued a statement in response to the misinterpretation of the test results. Under public pressure, Nongfu Spring's stock price continued to decline, and its market value shrank significantly within two days. The company then sent an executive director to Hong Kong for face-to-face negotiations. Today, the Consumer Council published a clarification on its official website, reclassifying the samples as "natural drinking water" and re-scoring them, while also expressing regret. Nongfu Spring responded that its products fully comply with standards and are safe to drink, and its stock price rose in response. [more…]

Jasmine Naibai's "Eternal Night Galaxy" collaboration event was plagued with problems, and the official apology failed to quell the drama fans' dissatisfaction.

Recently, the TV drama "Forever Night Star River" has surged in popularity, and the milk tea brand Molly Tea took the opportunity to launch a collaboration, but issues such as delayed merchandise, stock shortages, and reselling have led to collective complaints from fans of the show. Although the official side issued an emergency apology on the 15th and promised compensation, the limited-edition paper bags will not be available until the 30th at the earliest, prompting fans to exclaim that "the timeline is too long, and enthusiasm is being worn down." Why did this highly anticipated collaboration fail? Who exactly was hurt when the brand temporarily changed the schedule and store issues occurred frequently? Join Coffee Workshop as we review the entire incident and also take a look at the heartwarming recommendations Front Street Coffee has prepared for coffee lovers. [more…]

Manner apologizes for three store conflicts, Douyin account content completely cleared

Manner Coffee has been thrust into the spotlight of public opinion due to three incidents of conflicts between staff and customers that occurred over two consecutive days. The brand issued an apology statement through its official Weibo in the evening, pledging to make improvements, but netizens did not accept the content of the statement, especially expressing dissatisfaction over the lack of a clear response to the incident in which "a customer broke into the bar area and assaulted a staff member." At the same time, the content of Manner's two official Douyin accounts has been completely cleared, sparking further speculation. Behind the incidents, media investigations and revelations from former employees have exposed that under Manner's rapid expansion, frontline baristas face high-intensity work, heavy psychological pressure, and an unreasonable compensation system. As one of the few brands in the industry with a thousand stores that still insists on using semi-automatic espresso machines, how Manner can strike a balance between efficiency, quality, and employee rights has become an urgent issue to be resolved. [more…]

Guming employee's sign-making meme video sparks controversy, company apologizes and removes related content

During peak periods of exploding orders at tea beverage stores, staff inevitably make small mistakes such as forgetting to include straws, failing to affix expiration date labels, or knocking over tea containers, which are usually addressed with internal reminders or minor penalties. However, after employees at some Gu Ming stores filmed mocking videos featuring staff wearing placards around their necks, which were shared on social media, they sparked strong backlash from numerous netizens due to scenes involving employees having "crime" cardboard signs hung on their chests and their hands being cuffed with cup holders. The controversy centers on whether this form of imitation public shaming respects workers and whether it was appropriate for the official account to participate in posting it. Gu Ming subsequently responded that the video borrowed from a popular platform meme, has taken down the related content and apologized, and also distributed a thousand free drink vouchers. [more…]