Why did the Panamanian Geisha coffee labeling dispute matter?

Willem J. Boot, owner of Panama's Finca Sophia, publicly accused Taiwan buyer Black Gold Coffee and chain brand Oklao of selling products under the Finca Sophia name in 2023 and 2025 without ever purchasing from the estate. Oklao held a press conference on December 19 and apologized, admitting internal errors led to mislabeling.

Black Gold Coffee first called the claims untrue, then deleted its post and apologized. Authorities found the labeling did not match the source, and Oklao lost its Taichung Top 10 Souvenirs qualification and faces returns and compensation. The case shows why traceability documents matter when panama geisha coffee beans carry estate names and premium prices.

Taiwan's specialty coffee chain brand "Oklao" and coffee buyer "Black Gold Coffee" have recently become embroiled in a cross-border coffee bean controversy. Willem J. Boot, owner of the renowned Panamanian estate Finca Sophia, publicly accused both companies of selling coffee products under the "Finca Sophia" name in 2023 and 2025 without ever purchasing from the estate. The incident continues to escalate: Black Gold Coffee went from initially denying the allegations to deleting its post and issuing an apology, while Oklao held a press conference on December 19, where the chairman and general manager bowed in apology, admitting that internal operational errors led to the mislabeling of the estate name. Local authorities investigated and determined that the product labeling did not match the source, resulting in Oklao being stripped of its "Taichung Top 10 Souvenirs" award qualification and facing consumer returns and compensation. This article provides a complete timeline of the incident, both parties' responses, and subsequent impacts, allowing coffee enthusiasts to understand the full story behind this brand trust crisis.

▲

Click to follow | Daily specialty coffee culture magazine Coffee Workshop

Recently, Willem J. Boot, owner of Panama's Finca Sophia, posted on social media, naming Taiwan's well-known coffee buyer "Black Gold Coffee" and Taiwan's specialty coffee chain brand "Oklao," pointing out that neither company had ever purchased from the estate or its partners, yet both had marketed and sold products under the "Finca Sophia" name in 2023 and 2025.

On November 23, Willem J. Boot publicly accused Black Gold Coffee and Oklao through his personal social media account, stating that both had sold coffee products under the name "Finca Sophia" without authorization.

Facing the Panamanian estate owner's accusations, Black Gold Coffee and Oklao each issued statements on the same day in response, both attributing the incident to "name mislabeling" and "administrative process errors." Oklao further emphasized in its statement: "The Panamanian Geisha coffee sold by our company is indeed legally obtained from the place of origin, and comes with all certification documents as 'Panamanian Geisha coffee from the place of origin.'"

Black Gold Coffee initially took a firm tone in its November 23 statement, calling the accusations "untrue and misleading," but subsequently deleted the post and issued an apology to the estate owner on December 5. In its second statement, Black Gold Coffee no longer denied the estate owner's claims, but did not provide a clear explanation for the two instances of mislabeling in 2023 and 2025.

On December 6, Willem J. Boot issued another formal statement in the name of the estate, directly refuting Black Gold Coffee and Oklao's claims of "administrative errors" and characterizing the incident as an infringement of "misrepresentation."

It is understood that at the 2025 Taiwan International Coffee Show, Oklao displayed and sold a batch of Geisha washed coffee beans under the name "Finca Sophia" labeled "lot.144 harvest date 2025/5/12." After purchasing this batch of coffee beans, some consumers traced the source and found that the harvest date did not match the estate's publicly available information, so they sought verification from the estate owner.

The estate explained that the batch "FS14425" totaled 25 kilograms of coffee beans, all of which had been sold to mainland China, and that the lot.144 batch provided by Oklao did not match the batch actually sold by the estate. In response, Oklao stated that the coffee beans it sold came from another estate under Willem J. Boot, "Finca La Cabra," not "Finca Sophia," and gradually removed the related products from sale.

The two public accusations drew significant attention from all sectors of society. Following an investigation by local authorities, Oklao's "Finca Sophia Panama Sophia Estate Geisha Washed Golden Roast" coffee beans were found to have labeling inconsistent with the source of raw materials, allegedly violating relevant local laws and regulations.

On December 19, Oklao urgently held a press conference. At the event, Chairman Wang Hsin-chun and General Manager Tu Pei-ling bowed in apology, stating that due to internal operational process errors, the coffee estate name on the product was mislabeled. Although the actual production origin and the original label both belonged to the same estate alliance in Panama, this error still caused misunderstandings among consumers and the estate owner, for which they expressed sincere apologies.

The brand stated that immediately after the incident, it launched an internal review mechanism, quickly identified the problem, and fully removed the related products from sale. It also offered consumers unconditional returns, allowed consumers to choose any equivalent product, and additionally gifted a box of Geisha gift set.

The brand also stated that this week the estate owner verbally proposed other settlement options, which are still being finalized with local lawyers. It will uphold a responsible attitude, continue communicating with the other party, properly handle the matter, and promises to fully cooperate with the authorities' investigation. In addition, Oklao stated that it has thoroughly reviewed the relevant processes and strengthened operational review SOPs, the responsible personnel have been reassigned from their current positions, and the management team has also been adjusted to ensure similar incidents do not happen again in the future.

Although Oklao's senior management has admitted the mistake, provided compensation plans, and made every effort to remedy the situation, due to its violation of relevant regulations and the controversy that affected public perception, the organizers revoked its "Taichung Top 10 Souvenirs" award qualification. The previously obtained trophy and certificate were legally recalled, and it may not participate in the selection again for 3 years from the date of revocation.

Image source: Internet

Disclaimer: Some images in this article are from the Internet. For some content on the website such as images, we will respect the original author's copyright and indicate the source. However, due to the large quantity, some images and text may not have been credited in time. We ask for your understanding. If the original author has any disputes, they may contact the website for resolution. Once verified, we will immediately correct it. Compiled and edited by "Coffee Workshop." Please indicate the source when reposting. If there is any infringement, please inform us for removal. Thank you ~ !

The above content is compiled by CoffeeHunters, a coffee news website.