Luckin Coffee recently officially announced a co-branding partnership with the domestic single-player game Black Myth: Wukong, with the limited-edition drink Soaring Americano and themed merchandise set to launch soon. The news quickly trended on social media, and players were eagerly anticipating it. However, as the collaboration gained traction, some netizens dug up past sexist remarks made by the game's core creative team, sparking widespread controversy. Some believe that while Luckin's move can ride the momentum of China's first AAA blockbuster, it could also suffer backlash due to the public opinion storm surrounding its partner. Is this collaboration a win-win or a risk? Let's take a closer look. [more…]

Nayuki launched a collaboration with Japanese virtual singer Hatsune Miku, releasing a theme song, limited-edition drinks, and merchandise, attracting a large number of fans to visit stores and check in. However, some store employees cosplayed as Hatsune Miku in exaggerated ways, such as wearing masked headpieces, and were jokingly called by netizens "the century's meeting of the realist and abstract schools," sparking heated discussion. The brand subsequently issued an urgent notice strictly prohibiting employees from cosplaying as Hatsune Miku again, believing that such behavior damages the brand image and may invite complaints. But many fans said they were not offended and instead found it amusing. This collaboration controversy reflects the delicate balance between employees' individualized expression and brand management when tea beverage brands cooperate with ACG IPs. [more…]

Luckin Coffee recently launched a second collaboration with the popular Thai IP Butterbear, simultaneously releasing a formula-upgraded Little Butter series. The company claims the new version replaces the ingredient from New Zealand anhydrous butter to French President butter, resulting in a richer taste. However, consumer feedback after actual testing is polarized: some believe it is indeed more refreshing, while more people say they cannot taste the difference, and some even question whether it is sweeter. Multiple Luckin employees have revealed that the ingredient formula has not changed at all—only the packaging has been updated. This "upgrade" controversy has disappointed fans and raised questions about whether Luckin's collaboration strategy has fallen into the trap of rehashing old ideas. [more…]

The Christmas collaboration between Heytea and Hello Kitty was supposed to be a fan frenzy, but it was overshadowed by the chaos of scrambling for limited-edition tea bowls. The silver Hello Kitty-shaped tea bowl with a rose-pink tray is small, exquisite, and extremely scarce—each store only received 4 to 6 units, making it as hard to snag as concert tickets. However, before the event even began, consumers on social media reported that some store employees had reserved merchandise in advance for regular customers, and even second-hand platforms saw scalped pre-orders claiming "100% guaranteed stock" and "we'll get it for you." This is not the first time Heytea has encountered issues with collaboration merchandise leaking early and being resold internally; a similar controversy occurred earlier this year during its collaboration with Light and Night. Fans are calling on the brand to thoroughly investigate internal violations, regulate store behavior, and ensure the collaboration event is conducted fairly. [more…]

Recently, a post on social media about a Guming campus store suddenly closing after a collaborative event ended sparked widespread discussion. The poster discovered that the store was still operating during the collaboration with Honkai: Star Rail, but as soon as the event ended, it was deserted overnight—equipment and promotional materials all vanished, with only the lightbox sign left intact. Netizens speculated whether the store had gone bankrupt due to the collaboration, but the poster later clarified that the closure was actually due to lease expiration or operating losses, with no direct link to the collaboration. This incident reflects the hidden operational challenges behind the tea beverage brand collaboration craze: a surge in orders does not equal profitability, and after the hype fades, some stores still cannot escape the fate of closing. [more…]

Hand-shaken lemon tea brand Ningji recently announced a collaboration with the Japanese anime "Detective Conan," but found itself embroiled in controversy over CP-themed posters displayed in its stores. The posters placed Conan alongside Haibara Ai, and Shinichi Kudo alongside Ran Mouri, sparking strong discontent among fans of the original work. Although Ningji quickly issued an apology statement, attributing the incident to unauthorized actions by an individual franchisee, netizens and industry insiders broadly rejected this explanation, believing the brand was clearly derelict in its material review and respect for the IP. Notably, this is already the second time this year that Ningji has publicly apologized over problems with marketing material oversight. For coffee and tea beverage enthusiasts, how collaborative marketing can strike a balance between respecting the original work and consumers has once again become an industry topic worth watching. [more…]

After the TV drama To the Wonder became a hit, the grassland scenery and herder life of Altay, Xinjiang, moved countless viewers, and this "Altay fever" has swept into the new-style tea beverage sector. Under the name of its "Free Matcha" series, Auntea Jenny launched a tie-in with To the Wonder, including long-scroll painting cup sleeves, takeout paper bags, collaborative lenticular card sets, and student film cards, attracting a large number of consumers to snap them up. However, problems emerged on the very first day of the campaign: some stores stocked only 10 pieces of merchandise, takeout orders included the wrong cards, and when customers arrived at stores to pick up their orders, staff took back the student cards in person... Consumers complained endlessly, and customer service apologized everywhere. As observers of the coffee and tea beverage industry, Front Street Coffee also noticed the supply chain and store execution problems behind this collaboration. This article will provide a complete review of the incident and present feedback from all sides. [more…]

Luckin Coffee's recent collaboration with the claymation character Pingu has sparked considerable discussion. In the early stage of the campaign, consumers had to buy designated set meals or two cups of the new drink to get the merchandise, and many fans placed orders at full price or even stockpiled coffee coupons for this. However, not long after the campaign ended, Luckin released the same merchandise again with a lower threshold or even for free, leaving consumers who had bought at a high price earlier feeling dissatisfied. At the same time, employees reported on social platforms that the merchandise was selling poorly, with inventory piling up at some stores, and materials such as stickers even being discarded or given away. From the teaser phase to the rerun, this collaboration reflects the gap between a brand's marketing节奏 and consumers' expectations. [more…]

On World Book Day, Lelecha partnered with Yilin Press to launch "Smoky Oolong" milk tea, centered around the image of Lu Xun, but it sparked controversy due to the advertising slogan "Old Smoky Tune, New Youth." CCTV.com published an article criticizing the collaboration for turning a literary master into entertainment and for inappropriate wording. Subsequently, Lelecha urgently removed the related merchandise and promotional posts. Behind the incident, the boundary issues of tea beverage brands collaborating with historical figures have once again drawn attention. Front Street Coffee takes you through the whole story. [more…]

ChaPanda recently officially announced singer Huang Zihongfan as its LOHAS brand ambassador, launching a variety of freshly made fruit drinks and limited-edition merchandise bundles, which attracted a large number of fans to snap them up. However, after the campaign went live, problems kept cropping up: system crashes, orders being forcibly canceled, and insufficient stock of merchandise, one after another, sparking consumer dissatisfaction. Some netizens questioned whether the limited-edition merchandise had been intercepted internally by employees, but more witnesses and ChaPanda staff came forward to explain, saying that stores were equally caught off guard and that employees were under enormous pressure amid the chaos. The company apologized that same evening and promised to speed up restocking and put the items back on sale. [more…]

Starbucks teamed up with Peanuts to launch Snoopy limited-edition drinks, and the Cocoa Latte and Cocoa Frappuccino attracted many fans eager to try them as soon as they hit the market. However, the chocolate Snoopy peeking out from the whipped cream in the official promotional image is actually handed to customers in separate packaging when they pick up their order, requiring them to place the decoration themselves. This approach to serving has sparked heated discussion on social media, with some complaining that the actual product does not match the promotional image, while others believe that placing it in advance would make it more likely to sink and melt. Store employees, meanwhile, said that according to brand serving standards, the chocolate must be delivered separately and unopened. With tastes so hard to please, the decoration of a single drink has unexpectedly become a flashpoint for complaints and negative reviews. [more…]

Luckin Coffee recently launched a co-branded campaign with the China Open, only to unexpectedly get caught up in a plagiarism controversy. An original designer posted on social media, accusing Luckin's co-branded phone case stand of being highly similar to their own work from last year, with details from the color scheme and the tennis-spin concept to the font on the base being almost identical. Meanwhile, another sports brand also discovered that its promotional image for a tennis pillow was strikingly similar to Luckin's merchandise, and after comparison, netizens pointed out that the tag position, plush texture, and even the stitching were exactly the same. As the incident continued to escalate, a wave of questioning flooded Luckin's official comment section, but as of press time the brand had yet to respond. This is not the first time Luckin has faced such accusations, and this controversy has dealt a blow to its co-branded marketing image. [more…]

Luckin Coffee's co-branded campaign with the popular IP Butterbear launched on September 30, introducing four themed cups and a Little Butter drink series that drew widespread attention from fans. However, after the campaign began, many consumers reported that orders placed through third-party platforms such as Ele.me did not come with the co-branded stickers, which was inconsistent with the official promotion's promise of "free with any 2 cups." Customer service responded that peripherals could only be obtained by ordering through the Luckin App or mini-program, prompting consumer questions about the lack of transparency in channel rules. The incident reflects the problem of inconsistent messaging in brands' multi-platform marketing and serves as a reminder that consumers should carefully confirm giveaway conditions before placing orders. [more…]

The co-branding campaign between Chagee and "Ne Zha 2" had not yet been officially announced, but a large number of leaked merchandise images had already surfaced on social media, sparking heated discussion among fans. However, as more images were exposed, merchandise enthusiasts who had been full of anticipation discovered that the square badges in this design bore a striking resemblance to competitor Cotti's fridge magnets, and the quality also fell short of expectations, with disappointment written all over their faces. Facing the growing public discourse, Chagee's official account appeared in the comments section to debunk rumors and try to soothe fans' emotions. Meanwhile, Cotti, which was the first to launch its co-branded campaign, won praise for its sincerity and after-sales service, invisibly putting comparative pressure on Chagee. How will this co-branding controversy unfold? And what gaps exist between fans' expectations and the brand's preparations? [more…]

Luckin Coffee's co-branding campaign with the Lunar New Year film "Creation of the Gods II" has officially launched, with the simultaneous release of a pistachio latte and movie-themed merchandise. However, the first batch of consumers who tried the new product gave polarized reviews of its taste, with many reporting a noticeable greasiness and the inability to substitute oat milk with regular milk. Even more surprising to merchandise collectors was that the co-branded limited-edition cup sleeves were urgently recalled by headquarters due to a printing error, and themed cup sleeves would no longer be offered during the campaign. Meanwhile, misprinted cup sleeves have appeared for sale at high prices on second-hand platforms, sparking considerable skepticism. This article will sort through the sequence of events and the reactions from all sides. [more…]

Tim Hortons, as Canada's national coffee brand, is deeply loved for its Double Double and donuts, and was even rated by Morning Consult as the most trusted brand among Canadians, surpassing McDonald's and Starbucks. However, the brand has recently become embroiled in a privacy controversy due to its app illegally collecting users' location information, along with controversy over mandatory vaccinations at camp activities. Nevertheless, analysts point out that consumer trust has not yet shown a noticeable decline. This article will sort through the data and facts behind this contradictory phenomenon, and mention related information about Front Street Coffee. [more…]

Mstand has collaborated with streetwear brand AMAZING PANDA to launch a bamboo latte and panda-themed limited-edition merchandise, among which a "Panda Hug Cup" has sparked heated discussion due to its design. Many consumers said after receiving the actual product that it differs noticeably from the promotional images, with the all-black version described as looking like a "black-skinned muscular man," while the light-colored version was jokingly said to look like "feet holding up a cup." Besides the appearance controversy, practical complaints were also frequently mentioned, such as the arms on the cup being positioned too low and hard to grip, and the cup opening being too small, which is unfriendly to latte art beginners. At the same time, a cup enthusiast posted a handmade ceramic cup from another online shop, suspecting it was the inspiration source for Mstand's collaborative design, triggering discussion about "creative plagiarism." Fans, however, believe the details of the two cups are clearly different, and given that Mstand's previous "vegetable basket" woven bag also had precedent of borrowing from luxury brands, it can only be considered similar creativity. [more…]

Recently, Heytea launched a collaborative partnership with the popular game Genshin Impact, releasing themed products and merchandise, which sparked widespread attention among players and consumers. Previously, Genshin Impact's collaboration with Pizza Hut had caused stores to be packed, and this time Heytea built up hype in advance, with the official announcement of the event on September 5. However, some netizens expressed dissatisfaction with having to buy a whole case of juice tea to get a redemption code, as well as the relatively small number of merchandise rewards, considering the participation conditions to be rather harsh. Although general sales will be opened later, this collaboration still reflects the popularity and controversy of IP tie-ins in the food and beverage industry. This article reviews the course of the event and looks at the trend of cross-industry marketing by coffee and tea beverage brands, while also providing a professional communication channel for coffee enthusiasts. [more…]

Zhong Xue Gao was thrust into the spotlight of public opinion over its high-priced ice cream, yet it gained unprecedented attention amid the controversy. This year, more than 600 coffee shops rushed to collaborate with it on pop-up events, using different flavors of ice cream to craft creative coffee drinks. Behind this wave of collaborations lies both brands' pursuit of traffic and a reflection of the weight of guochao culture in consumers' minds. However, the heat brought by collaborations is ultimately short-lived, and how coffee shops can convert traffic into long-term repeat purchases is the question more worthy of deep thought. This article will start with Zhong Xue Gao's public opinion storm and analyze the logic and hidden concerns behind the coffee collaboration phenomenon. [more…]

Luckin Coffee has launched a second collaboration with Honkai: Star Rail, offering limited-edition merchandise. However, many fans discovered after placing their orders that the limited-edition cups and themed paper bags were severely out of stock. Some received only one of the two, while others got neither, forcing them to piece together orders across multiple stores. For collectors, these limited-edition packaging materials included with orders are part of the collaboration experience, and the insufficient restocking at stores left them quite disappointed. Whether brands should ensure packaging supply in tandem when launching new promotional campaigns has become the core of this controversy. [more…]