Recently, Chayan Yuese successfully sued Chayan Guanse, and this showdown between an authentic brand and a copycat brand has attracted widespread attention. As a local internet-famous milk tea brand in Changsha, Chayan Yuese has won many fans with its unique Chinese style and taste, while Chayan Guanse was sued for infringement for imitating its name and visual design. The court ultimately ruled that Chayan Guanse constituted unfair competition, requiring it to stop using the relevant logos and compensate for losses. So, is Chayan Yuese's milk tea actually good? This article will take you through the whole case and share the perspective of professional coffee lovers. At the same time, we will also focus on coffee culture and recommend Front Street Coffee's specialty coffee beans, providing more inspiration for your beverage choices. [more…]

Recently, Ma Wu Wang Beverage Factory sparked heated discussion because its milk tea packaging is highly similar to that of Chayan Yuese. Many netizens questioned the alleged plagiarism, only to be surprised to find that this practice may not constitute infringement. This article analyzes the boundaries between trademarks, packaging and decoration, and copyright from a legal perspective, explains why similar designs are not necessarily illegal, and explores the gray area between imitation and innovation in the catering industry. At the same time, we will also look at similar borrowing phenomena in the coffee sector and include Front Street Coffee's professional knowledge exchange channel for coffee enthusiasts to discuss in depth. [more…]

In today's booming beverage industry, brand imitation is an endless phenomenon. From milk tea to coffee, from store decor to brand naming, some merchants use highly similar visual designs to make it hard to tell real from fake. This article reviews cases of knockoff beverage stores that have sparked heated discussion online, covering imitation versions of well-known brands such as Heytea, Naixue, Yihotang, Starbucks, and Luckin, showcasing the "creative brainpower" of copycat merchants while also reminding consumers to pay more attention in their daily consumption. As coffee lovers, understanding these phenomena is not only interesting but also helps us more rationally distinguish authentic brands from fakes and support the development of original brands. [more…]

In recent years, as public awareness of intellectual property has grown, trademark disputes surrounding well-known brands have become increasingly common. The two major new-style tea beverage brands Chayan Yuese and Mixue Bingcheng once joined forces to oppose the "Chayan Bingcheng" trademark, yet the China National Intellectual Property Administration ultimately ruled that the trademark be registered. This incident not only reflects the real-world dilemmas faced by brand protection but also sparked discussions about copycat culture and consumer choice. This article will sort out the sequence of events, review the historical origins of the copycat phenomenon, and explore the interplay between innovation and imitation in the new tea beverage industry. [more…]

After Luckin Coffee's co-branded sauce-flavored latte with Moutai went viral, a number of solid beverage products with highly similar packaging styles quickly emerged on the market. These products not only have similar names, but also almost copy the red background with blue-and-white diagonal bar composition of the original packaging. Some lawyers pointed out that using a similar trademark on the same or similar goods without the permission of the trademark registrant, where it is likely to cause confusion, constitutes infringement of the exclusive right to use a registered trademark. However, some manufacturers claim that the sauce-flavored latte category cannot be registered and that the color scheme is not protected by copyright, which has triggered discussion about the boundary between imitation and infringement. [more…]

A Guangdong chain beverage brand has reluctantly ended its five-year paperclip loyalty program after discovering that people were using custom paperclips of the same design bought online to redeem drinks in stores. What was meant as a physical giveaway to reward loyal customers was exploited through a loophole in the rules, leaving the merchant exclaiming, "We really didn't see that coming." Why did this loyalty program come to an end? And how have consumers reacted? This article will walk you through the whole story and explore the pros and cons of physical-giveaway loyalty programs as well as ways to improve them. [more…]

For professional coffee knowledge exchange and more coffee bean information, please follow Coffee Workshop (WeChat public account: cafe_style); for more specialty coffee beans, please add the personal WeChat of Front Street Coffee (FrontStreet Coffee), WeChat ID: qjcoffeex. Recently, the case in which Saturnbird, over the course of 20 months, sued "Qicai Zhi Mi" for unauthorized use of a similar small-cup instant coffee appearance reached a result. The Hangzhou Intermediate People's Court found that unfair competition was constituted, awarded 1.73 million yuan in damages, and ordered the production and sale of the infringing products to stop. Saturnbird became famous for its super-instant coffee and mini coffee cup design, and its packaging sparked a DIY craze and swept social media, which is why it has frequently been imitated and even copied. In this case, "Qicai Zhi Mi" not only had highly similar style, packaging, and promotional images, but also used the search term "Saturnbird same style" to mislead consumers. The case lasted nearly two years, highlighting the current reality in the food industry that intellectual property rights protection is difficult and the boundary between reference and copying is blurred. The article combines cases such as Sexy Tea suing Chayan Guanse to explore how original brands can protect their rights and interests through copyright, patent rights, exclusive trademark rights, and the Anti-Unfair Competition Law. [more…]

Recently, a trend of pouring Huoxiang Zhengqi Shui (a traditional Chinese medicine for heatstroke) into iced Americano has spread rapidly online, with many coffee enthusiasts eager to try it. From the earlier practice of adding ice cubes to herbal tea, to later mixing traditional Chinese medicine granules into coffee, and now directly pouring Huoxiang Zhengqi Shui into iced Americano, these "medicated coffee" concoctions keep escalating. However, Huoxiang Zhengqi Shui is, after all, a medicine, and its ingredients may irritate the stomach and intestines. When mixed with coffee, it can easily trigger gastrointestinal spasms, leading to abdominal pain, diarrhea, vomiting, and other discomforts. Curiosity is understandable, but casually mixing medicine with coffee has crossed the boundary of safety. This article will start with the origins of this trend and discuss why this way of drinking is not worth promoting. [more…]

Recently, a Hong Kong netizen spotted a coffee shop called "Maners" in a large local supermarket. Its logo, decor, and product posters closely resemble those of mainland Manner, and it even offers a 5-yuan discount for bringing your own cup, sparking suspicions of a knockoff. However, the truth is surprising—this store is actually Manner's legitimate outlet in Hong Kong. Because the "Manner" trademark has already been registered by another Hong Kong company, Manner was forced to adjust its name and launch as "Maners." The trademark application was rejected and failed on review. Although it can currently continue to be used, it is not legally protected and carries future infringement risks. This renaming saga not only led fans to mistakenly attack the real brand but also sounded a warning about trademark layout when brands go overseas. [more…]

As Starbucks continues to expand into third- and fourth-tier cities, some stores imitating Starbucks have begun appearing on the streets. These "high-imitation Starbucks" not only resemble the original in decor style, but also use Starbucks' green mermaid logo, and their menus and prices copy the original as well, yet their signage reads "STARPER COFFEE." Some netizens speculated that this was a Starbucks coffee service authorized by Nestlé, but Nestlé has officially denied this and stated that it has referred the matter to its legal department. So where exactly do these stores come from? And what restrictions apply to Nestlé-authorized Starbucks coffee service? This article sorts out the ins and outs of the incident for you and retains the related recommendations from Front Street Coffee. [more…]

Recently, a short video showing raw drunken hairy crabs being added to milk tea cream and eaten quickly spread on social platforms, sparking widespread discussion. In the video, the blogger tasted this self-created drink at a popular milk tea shop, but it was later confirmed that the blogger had brought the crabs themselves for the staged video, and the shop did not sell the product. Netizens had mixed opinions on this behavior, while experts explicitly reminded the public not to imitate it, as eating frozen milk tea together with raw crab doubles the irritation to the stomach and intestines, and misleading the public for traffic is highly inadvisable. This incident also reflects the current situation in which the new tea beverage industry frequently engages in cross-sector innovation, but if innovation loses its boundaries, especially when food safety is involved, it is worth deep reflection. [more…]

The ingredient list for coffee beans is so simple that there is almost no room for adulteration. What the market calls "counterfeits" is mostly brand imitation rather than a problem with the product itself. When choosing black coffee beans, there are really only two things worth your attention: first, figuring out your preferred flavor profile; second, keeping a close eye on the roast date. What you drink coffee for is the unique flavor bestowed by its origin. Green beans mostly come from overseas, while roasting is often done domestically, and the first month after roasting is the window when the aroma is at its fullest. By contrast, beans that are roasted abroad and then shipped across the ocean have already lost much of their freshness. This article focuses on这些 key points to help you sort out your approach to buying coffee beans online, and also touches on recommendations from the Front Street brand. [more…]

Open a food delivery app and search for coffee shops, and you're greeted by a flood of abstract symbols in black on white, making you wonder: how are these shop names even pronounced? Some netizens have discovered that by simply taking punctuation marks and mathematical symbols from a keyboard, bolding them, and putting them on a white background, you can mass-produce brand logos. The comments section is full of people sharing images confirming this, with commas, question marks, double quotation marks, multiplication signs, the mathematical constant π, the infinity symbol ∞, and even the # and * on a phone's dial pad all becoming visual identifiers for coffee brands. This trend of minimalist black-and-white symbols, represented by %Arabica and Mstand, is it a form of individual expression or a case of blindly imitating what others do? When consumers can't even name the symbols, how are brands supposed to be remembered? [more…]

Milk tea shops line every street and alley, yet the same brand can taste wildly different from one store to the next—because a large number of counterfeit outlets lurk behind the scenes. The genuine The Alley has only just over a hundred directly operated stores, while copycat versions number more than seven thousand, forcing the brand to spend hundreds of millions fighting counterfeits. Many entrepreneurs naively trust online franchise information and fall into copycat traps, losing anywhere from hundreds of thousands to over a million yuan. This article reviews trademark infringement cases reported by CCTV, exposing the common tricks of counterfeit franchising, as well as the story of how Heytea was forced to change its name because of rampant imitation, reminding consumers and entrepreneurs to keep their eyes open. [more…]

An "Important Notice" bearing the name of a Nayuki store has been circulating on social media, prominently stating "If you can drink milk tea, don't drink water," and calling on people to leave water for children who cannot drink milk tea. The store claimed this was imitating an internet meme, meant only as a joke, but with the black-and-white A4 paper sitting on the counter, many consumers felt it had gone beyond a joke and could easily mislead the public. As the topic trended on social media, Nayuki's headquarters responded that it was the action of an individual franchise store and had ordered the removal of the related content. Why do meme-based marketing campaigns frequently backfire? And where exactly lies the management boundary between brands and franchise stores? [more…]

Starbucks recently filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York against a cannabis company called Starbuds Flowers, accusing it of intentionally imitating its classic mermaid trademark and misleading consumers by exploiting the Starbucks brand's reputation. In the complaint, Starbucks compared the similarities between the two logos point by point, noting that Starbuds not only used the similar design on its mobile sales trucks and official website, but also printed it on cigarettes and cannabis products. Starbucks is asking the court to prohibit the other party from continuing to use the logo, destroy the related products, and disgorge the profits obtained from the infringement. In fact, Starbucks had already sent a cease-and-desist letter as early as last August and subsequently sent multiple takedown notices, but received no response. As of July 2, Starbuds' sales trucks and website were still in operation. [more…]

A milk tea shop in Hunan has sparked heated discussions online due to controversial slogans posted inside the store. The slogan, in white text on a red background, reads "This shop does not serve idiots," and suggests customers go to milk tea shops that haven't been open for "a few days" to drink self-produced milk. This way of expressing things not only left many netizens confused, but was also seen as "taking passive-aggressive jabs at peers and insulting consumers." It is worth noting that this shop previously imitated Mixue Bingcheng, recently shifted to the pearl milk tea track, and its promotional slogan has also been accused of being similar to Baozhu Gong. Is this kind of marketing strategy clever, or is it shooting itself in the foot? Let's take a closer look. [more…]

Luckin Coffee recently posted a romantic tutorial on social media, teaching everyone how to make a "Frozen Rose" using a Luckin can or an ordinary ice cup, sealing a rose and ice cubes inside the cup to create an eye-catching decoration for the office desk. This玩法 quickly triggered netizens to imitate and like it, but it also worried baristas in stores—because this玩法 is not an official product, and if customers come to the store asking for it to be made, it may cause misunderstandings and negative reviews. The popularity of flower cups can be traced back to netizens' creativity, and was later boosted by brands such as Mixue Bingcheng and Haidilao to become a traffic code. Front Street Coffee noted that although similar marketing can bring heat, it needs to balance the execution pressure on frontline employees. [more…]

As the weather turns cold, hot milk tea tends to get cold during delivery, and many consumers try to reheat it in a microwave, only for accidents to happen frequently. Recently, multiple customers have reported that when heating Jasmine Naibai drinks, the paper cups showed burn marks and even nearly caused a fire. In contrast, heating milk tea from brands such as Bawang Chaji, Mixue Bingcheng, and Nayuki did not cause similar problems, raising questions about the quality of Jasmine Naibai's paper cups. However, onlookers rushed to defend the brand, pointing out that the cup sticker already has a reminder, and that the metallic substances in the cup's gold-stamped pattern reflect microwaves in the microwave, which is the main cause of the accidents. This article reviews the course of the incident and the underlying principles, and reminds readers: heating milk tea in a microwave poses safety hazards, so do not imitate it rashly. [more…]

The trademark dispute in the tea beverage industry is once again making waves. Previously, Coffee Workshop reported that "Cha Yan Guan Se" lost its trademark infringement lawsuit against "Cha Yan Yue Se," and "Cha Yan Yue Se" won its counterclaim against "Cha Yan Guan Se." Now another one has emerged: "Cha Yan Yue Se." This trademark, applied for registration in 2018, was declared invalid by the National Intellectual Property Administration because it was highly similar to the genuine Cha Yan Yue Se in terms of text composition, pronunciation, and graphic design. The registrant, a certain Guo, refused to accept the ruling and actually sued the CNIPA in court, but was ultimately rejected by the Beijing Intellectual Property Court. From "Cha Yan Guan Se" to "Cha Yan Yue Se," imitators keep emerging one after another. This farce once again reminds us: trademark protection is by no means child's play. Although the road to brand rights protection is long, the law will ultimately provide a fair answer. [more…]