What does the FDA plant-based milk labeling draft mean for coffee?

On February 22 the U.S. FDA released a draft industry guidance asking plant-based milk products to state their nutritional content clearly on packaging and explain how they differ from cow's milk. Oat milk has become a common option in coffee shops, and the draft pushes back on the assumption that these drinks are automatically healthier.

Medical experts say many people choose plant-based milk out of trend rather than lactose intolerance, without knowing its nutritional content. For taste, many products add vegetable oil and sugar, which can raise risks tied to obesity and cardiovascular disease. The same scrutiny applies to coffee knowledge around milk choices and the nutritional value of coffee drinks.

In recent years, plant-based milk has quickly risen to fame under labels such as eco-friendly and healthy, with oat milk in particular becoming almost a standard offering in coffee shops. But many medical experts point out that many people choose plant-based milk not because they are lactose intolerant, but because they are blindly following the trend, without understanding its actual nutritional value. To this end, on February 22 the U.S. FDA released a draft industry guidance requiring plant-based milk products to clearly indicate nutritional content on their packaging and explain how they differ from cow's milk. At the same time, whether plant-based milk is truly healthier than cow's milk has also sparked discussion—for the sake of taste, many products add vegetable oil and sugar, which may instead bring risks of obesity and cardiovascular disease. This article will walk you through this controversy surrounding plant-based milk labeling and health.

For professional coffee knowledge exchange and more coffee bean information, please follow Coffee Workshop (WeChat public account cafe_style)

For more specialty coffee beans, please add the private WeChat of Front Street Coffee (FrontStreet Coffee), WeChat ID: qjcoffeex

In recent years, more and more plant-based milk companies have made "eco-friendly," "healthy," and "milk substitute" their core selling points, precisely targeting Generation Z young people's concerns about health, ethics, and environmental protection.

Driven by both strong supply and demand, plant-based milk has set off a consumer trend. As dairy alternatives grow increasingly popular, plant-based milk is being used more and more frequently, with oat milk especially prominent.

In the coffee world, plant-based milk has become an almost indispensable option. Many customers walking into a coffee shop will often first ask whether oat milk is available. If the shop does not offer it, they often press further: why don't you carry plant-based milk? After all, it's healthier and more nutritious!

Faced with ever-rising demand for plant-based milk, a medical doctor pointed out that more and more people choose plant-based milk not because of lactose intolerance, but more because they are influenced by the trend. In fact, people are unclear about the nutritional content of plant-based milk and whether it is truly healthy.

Therefore, some argue that plant-based milk packaging should provide clear labels to convey necessary information to consumers, helping them make wiser nutritional and purchasing decisions when buying products for themselves and their families.

To this end, on February 22, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) published a draft industry guidance on the naming of plant-based foods, which are often marketed and sold as milk substitutes.

The draft notes that the plant-based milk industry often uses the term "milk substitute," but its nutritional content is not the same as that of cow's milk. According to the nutritional standards for liquid milk alternatives established by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) Food and Nutrition Service, plant-based milk packaging should explain how the product compares with cow's milk. For example, labels could state: "Contains less vitamin D and calcium than milk."

The reason dairy products, including cow's milk, are recommended as part of a healthy diet in dietary guidelines is that cow's milk provides multiple key nutrients, such as protein, vitamins A and B-12, as well as calcium, potassium, and vitamin D, which are currently generally underconsumed. The dietary guidelines classify only fortified soy beverages in the dairy group, because their nutritional content is similar to that of cow's milk.

Other plant-based milks, including nut milk, coconut milk, oat milk, and legume milks other than soy, differ greatly in nutritional content from cow's milk, and therefore cannot truly serve as "milk substitutes."

The FDA's medical doctor said: "Getting adequate nutrition from cow's milk and fortified soy beverages is especially important for children's growth and development. Parents and caregivers should understand that many plant-based alternatives do not have the same nutritional content as cow's milk."

Therefore, clearly labeling nutritional content on plant-based milk and providing comparisons is very necessary. Labels can provide consumers with valuable information and help them choose healthier foods.

Is plant-based milk really healthier than cow's milk? At present, the vast majority of plant-based milk packaging only indicates the content of fat, protein, fiber, and sugar, and this information cannot directly reflect the full nutritional picture of plant-based milk.

In the production process of plant-based milk on the market, vegetable oil and sugar are usually added to enhance the smooth texture and flavor of the finished product. At the same intake level, compared with the milk fat and lactose in animal milk, vegetable oil and fructose are more likely to lead to obesity and cardiovascular disease.

Image source: Internet

The above content is compiled by CoffeeHunters, a coffee news website.