What does handling coffee shop safety mean after a chandelier injury?
A man at a Maan Coffee branch in Kaifu District, Changsha, stood up from his seat on May 23, failed to see the low-hanging crystal chandelier above the table and struck his head, which bled heavily and required hospital treatment. His wife said a return visit the next day showed some chandeliers still sat too low above the tables, with no corrections made.
The shop first said it would handle the case through insurance and asked for income records, then reversed course and offered 1,000 yuan; after negotiation the figure rose to 2,000 yuan plus a promise to fix the fittings. A lawyer said the shop bears responsibility for the non-compliant installation, while the customer also carries partial responsibility for not exercising due care.
Besides ensuring food safety, what other unexpected risks might lurk in coffee shops? Recently, a man in Changsha hit his head on a low-hanging crystal chandelier when he stood up at a Maan Coffee, bleeding on the spot and seeking medical treatment, which sparked a compensation dispute. The shop initially promised to go through insurance but then reneged, only willing to pay 1,000 yuan; after negotiation, the amount was finally raised to 2,000 yuan along with a commitment to make rectifications. A lawyer pointed out that the shop bears responsibility for installing the chandelier in a non-compliant manner, while the consumer also bears partial responsibility for failing to exercise due safety care. This article recounts the incident and analyzes the relevant legal liabilities.
▲
Click to follow | Daily specialty coffee culture magazine Coffee Workshop
As part of the food and beverage industry, besides guarding against food safety issues, what other unexpected risks might lurk in coffee shops? Recently, a customer in a coffee shop was hit on the head by a chandelier and suffered a bloody injury.
According to the Xiaoxiang Morning Herald, on May 23, a man was at a Maan Coffee in Kaifu District, Changsha, discussing matters with someone. When he stood up from his seat, he failed to notice the large crystal chandelier directly above the table and hit his head on it. He then touched it with his hand and found it was bleeding profusely, so he rushed to the hospital for treatment.
After the incident, the man and his wife immediately contacted the person in charge of the coffee shop to negotiate compensation for the injury. The shop initially said it could go through the insurance process, but required the party involved to provide proof of income flow. However, after they submitted the income records, they were told the next day that "insurance cannot be used," and the shop was only willing to pay 1,000 yuan in compensation. The couple found this unacceptable and explicitly stated they did not agree to that compensation plan.
Speaking about the chandelier that caused the man's injury, his wife said: "The day after the incident, I made a special trip to the store and found that some chandeliers were still too low relative to the tables, and the staff still had not made rectifications." In addition, Maan Coffee has several branches in Changsha, all with this style of decoration, and it is very necessary for the shop to rectify such safety hazards as soon as possible.
On May 25, a reporter from the Xiaoxiang Morning Herald accompanied the couple to the coffee shop and reenacted the incident on site. "Because this table can be moved, if the chandelier happens to be directly overhead, it is very easy for your head to hit it when you stand up." Ms. Liu also walked back and forth in the aisle several times: "In just a few meters, I already hit (the lamp) twice."
In response to doubts that the chandeliers in the shop posed safety hazards, the person in charge of the coffee shop said, "These lamps serve lighting and decorative purposes, and some of the lower ones have already been adjusted once." The lamps' positions can only be adjusted at night by staff from the engineering department. "The engineering department has its standards and will adjust the positions until there are no safety hazards." As for why insurance was not used, the shop said it was because the man's medical expenses did not reach the 500-yuan threshold, so insurance could not be used.
With the reporter's involvement, both sides continued negotiations, and the shop finally agreed to compensate the couple 2,000 yuan and promised to inform them of the rectified store environment through pictures, videos, and other means.
Regarding the above situation, the lawyer said that both the store and the customer bear responsibility. The store cannot install chandeliers in violation of regulations, and customers also have an obligation to pay attention to protecting their own safety.
According to relevant standards, generally the indoor installation of chandeliers should not be lower than 1.8 meters from the ground; otherwise, it is non-compliant. If this causes injury to consumers, fault-based compensation liability must be borne. Consumers also have an obligation to pay attention to protecting their own safety, and if injury is caused by their own reasons, they should also bear certain responsibility. Both parties can negotiate to handle compensation matters, and if negotiation fails, they can file a lawsuit in court. The court will divide responsibility and allocate losses according to the degree of fault of both parties.
Disclaimer: Some images in this article are from the internet. For some content on the website, such as images, we will respect the original author's copyright and indicate the source. However, due to the large volume, a few images and texts may not have been credited in time. Please forgive us. If the original author has any dispute, they may contact the website for handling. Once verified, we will correct it immediately. Compiled and edited by "Coffee Workshop." Please indicate the source when reposting. If there is infringement, please inform us for deletion. Thank you~!
The above content is compiled by CoffeeHunters, a coffee news website.
