Why does the Manner and St Helena coffee crossover draw more criticism?

On June 24, Manner Coffee released a co-branded drink with Helena Rubinstein, the L'Oreal-owned skincare label behind the Green Treasure Bottle. The launch used green limited-edition packaging and a self-healing theme aimed at Generation Z, but it drew criticism from the teaser onward, with app crashes, unclear rules, uneven store execution, and cup sleeve copy that many readers called bleak.

The backlash centers on mismatched audiences. The Green Treasure Bottle is the most entry-level item in the HR line and focuses on barrier repair and soothing, yet 50ml costs 1,580 yuan on the official site, out of reach for most office workers. The Manner drink is a matcha milk beverage without coffee, offering little to regular coffee drinkers.

On June 24, Manner Coffee launched a co-branded drink "A Cup of Youth Restored" with HR Helena's Green Treasure Bottle, a high-end skincare brand under L'Oréal Group, featuring green limited-edition packaging and a "self-healing" concept to engage Generation Z. However, the campaign sparked controversy from teaser to launch: some netizens compared the collaboration to "the marriage of a high-ranking official's daughter and a factory manager's son," with issues such as unclear rules, app crashes, inconsistent store execution, and bleak cup sleeve copy emerging one after another. Is this seemingly win-win crossover a brand breakout or just talking to itself? This article will review the entire event and retain professional coffee information channels like Front Street Coffee.

On June 24, MANNER COFFEE officially announced a collaboration with HR Helena's Green Treasure Bottle, the top luxury beauty brand under L'Oréal Group, to launch the co-branded drink "A Cup of Youth Restored." This new product features green limited-edition packaging, with the official slogan stating: "Harness the power of self-healing, embrace confusion, restore youth overnight. Engage in a youthful dialogue with Generation Z consumers (typically referring to those born between 1995 and 2009) in a brand-new way, shining with green to highlight outstanding youth."

However, as soon as the collaboration news broke, discussions among netizens followed. Some compared the partnership to "the marriage of a high-ranking official's daughter and a factory manager's son," a comment that received many likes, with numerous netizens expressing agreement.

Generation Z consumers generally lean towards high cost-effectiveness, while the Green Treasure Bottle, as the most entry-level item in HR's product line, focuses on anti-inflammatory stabilization, barrier repair, and soothing moisturization, but its pricing is not affordable—50ml costs 1,580 yuan on the official website, making it difficult for ordinary office workers to afford long-term. In contrast, Manner's co-branded product this time is a matcha milk drink without coffee, which has limited appeal for coffee consumers.

HR positions itself as high-end luxury skincare, with core users being those with strong spending power on skincare products; Manner focuses on affordable specialty coffee, with core users seeking a bourgeois experience but valuing cost-effectiveness. From the perspective of brand positioning, it is difficult for the two to resonate.

Although the official side did teasers in advance, consumers on both sides did not form effective forwarding and dissemination (To be honest, the author only learned about it by scrolling through Xiaohongshu...). Six days after the event, the overall response was lukewarm. Due to vague official tweets, many netizens bluntly said: "If you can't play, don't play."

The official campaign tweet stated that by June 25, those who follow Manner's official account and share the tweet to Moments, and wear green clothing to the store to order on June 25, can receive 1 free limited-edition co-branded drink, with each person limited to 1 participation. However, the tweet never mentioned that the "free with green" event was time-limited, ending at 17:00... causing many who worked on weekends and planned to participate after work to miss out.

During the event period from June 24 to July 15, customers who purchase large drinks at full price can participate in the hidden cup sleeve activity. Those who draw a hidden cup sleeve with "What is freedom" can redeem a co-branded limited-edition coffee cup; if they receive a super hidden "What is freedom" cup sleeve with a unique code, they can redeem a 50ml HR Green Treasure Bottle worth 1,580 yuan.

However, some netizens reported that after drawing cup sleeves at certain stores, staff were unwilling to provide the co-branded packaging bags, stating that if you draw a cup sleeve, you cannot ask for a packaging bag—you can only choose one... The official tweet did not mention this rule.

Other netizens said that baristas at some stores did not proactively remind customers of this activity, and only when asked why there was no cup sleeve did the barista casually grab one. Meanwhile, the text on the cup sleeves was completely unobstructed, like the emperor's new clothes, with everything laid bare...

On the 24th, before Manner stores even opened, people on Xianyu had already started reselling hidden cup sleeves. The cup redemption sleeve originally worth 158 yuan was hyped up to 188 yuan... This raised questions: How does Manner ensure employees don't draw cup sleeves in advance? Some netizens also reported that some stores did not proactively provide cup sleeves, leaving no chance to even participate in the draw...

On June 27, because ordering the co-branded drink via the mini-program from 12:30 daily allowed customers to receive a 3ml Green Treasure Bottle sample set, many consumers were unable to use the Manner mini-program normally to order other products. Manner officially responded immediately: "Due to the explosive rush of the MANNER x HR Helena co-branded event, the server is undergoing emergency repairs," and apologized to consumers who could not use the mini-program normally.

On June 28, Manner apologized on its official Weibo, moving the event start time to 12:00 and hoping everyone would order during off-peak hours. But many netizens still reported system lag, with other drinks still unable to be ordered normally, and by the time orders went through, lunch break was over, greatly diminishing the purchasing experience for ordinary consumers.

Regarding this collaboration, some marketing-savvy netizens analyzed that it is actually a win-win: for Manner, HR is a high-end brand, and the collaboration can elevate the brand's level and strengthen the audience's perception of its ultimate cost-effectiveness; for HR, this collaboration is "spending little to achieve much," using Manner's store distribution to let more mass consumers learn about the brand. By distributing samples, it can stimulate potential users and attract Generation Z to "get into it."

But! The campaign copy is pieced together, core information is unclear, and the co-branded product's tone has weak relevance to both brands, leaving consumers unable to feel the purpose of the activity. Cross-border cooperation emphasizes mutual traffic diversion—you have the audience I need, I have the audience you need, expanding and blending with each other to ultimately achieve conversion. At the same time, both parties must convey the same story to resonate with consumers, in order to expand brand voice in a short time.

Although this collaboration made HR's Green Treasure Bottle more "down-to-earth," and Manner is a brand that white-collar workers buy daily, there is some overlap in their audiences from this perspective. However, due to vague activity rules and Manner's backend technology failing to hold up, problems emerged as soon as the co-branded event launched, with netizens complaining far more than praising.

The co-branded drink itself is an ice-cream-flavored matcha milk with high sweetness. Many netizens said that people who truly care about their skin condition would not drink such a sugary beverage. Even if HR distributed samples, a single trial makes it hard to see effects, and very few actually came to purchase after using them.

The copy on the co-branded cup sleeves this time is also quite heart-wrenching... "Is being hooked the real love?" "Do social phobics envy social butterflies?" "On which day did childhood end?" "Is makeup self-deception?" "Want to zone out." "What is freedom?"... Do these fit the theme of "A Cup of Youth Restored"? Full of bleak words, one cannot feel the vitality of returning to youth.

This is probably also why everyone complains—it's traffic...

Image source: Internet

For professional coffee knowledge exchange and more coffee bean information, please follow Coffee Workshop (WeChat public account: cafe_style)

For more specialty coffee beans, please add private WeChat Front Street Coffee (FrontStreet Coffee), WeChat ID: qjcoffeex

The above content is compiled by CoffeeHunters, a coffee news website.