Wednesday, September 16 2026

Recommendations for Non-Acidic Coffee Beans | What Are the Characteristics and Differences of Light, Medium, and Dark Roast Coffee Beans? What Water Temperature Is Suitable for Brewing Light, Medium, and Dark Roast Coffee Beans?

December 18, 2025
qj

咖啡豆3


Some friends have mentioned, "Why doesn't Front Street's coffee beans have a roast level indicated?" In response, Front Street plans to share knowledge about coffee roast levels with everyone through an article.


I believe everyone's understanding of coffee bean roast levels is basically that if it's sour, it's a light roast, and if it's bitter, it's a dark roast. Of course, within the industry, such a simple classification is not used. Currently, a more scientific distinction uses the Agtron color value (caramelization analysis value) as the basis for coffee roast level.


烘焙3030


During coffee roasting, it is now generally considered that the boundary for being "done" is the "first crack." After the first crack, the beans can be removed at any time; the earlier they are removed, the lighter the roast level of the coffee beans; the later they are removed, the darker the roast level.

Using the Agtron color value, roast levels can be divided into 8 categories. The higher the color value, the lighter the roast level, and vice versa.


烘焙度对照895


The lightest roast level is called Light Roast, with an Agtron color value of 95, and the removal time is approximately when the first crack is密集 (the beans are still crackling as they are removed). Generally, the coffee's flavor will exhibit bright acidity.


With an Agtron color value of 85, it is Cinnamon Roast, and the removal time is around the end of the first crack (when the cracking sound has just stopped, or only sporadic cracking remains). Generally, coffee beans at this level will have a flavor profile dominated by acidity, with a sweet and fragrant note.


花魁8


With an Agtron color value of 75, it is called Medium Roast, and the removal time is approximately after the first crack ends (when the cracking sound completely stops). At this level, the coffee's flavor will be mainly sweet, with a slight fruity acidity.


With an Agtron color value of 65, it is called High Roast, and the removal time is approximately after the first crack ends and before the second crack begins (about a 1-2 minute silent period). The flavor will exhibit nutty and caramel notes, balanced, with no sourness.


With an Agtron color value of 55, it is called City Roast, and the removal time is approximately when the second crack begins (after a period of silence, one or two faint cracking sounds appear). At this point, the flavor is more bitter, with a heavier caramel aroma.


IMG_绿标瑰夏


With an Agtron color value of 45, it is called Full City Roast, and the removal time is approximately before the second crack密集 (before the crackling sound is heard). At this point, the coffee is already quite dark, and the taste is more burnt, bitter, and rich.


With an Agtron color value of 35, it is called French Roast, and the removal time is approximately during the second crack密集 (when the crackling sound is heard again, but deeper than the first). At this point, the coffee beans have begun to exude oil.


With an Agtron color value of 25, it is called Italian Roast, and the removal time is approximately at the end of the second crack (after the密集 sounds). At this point, the coffee beans are pitch black and shiny, with oil already seeping out onto the bean surface.


深烘咖啡豆出油

Actually, for these 8 roast levels, after the color value of 65, the coffees are all mainly bitter, but end consumers may not necessarily encounter all of them. For example, nowadays coffee beans are no longer roasted until they are oily like before, and it is basically hard to see French Roast and Italian Roast these two roast levels.

If this set of industry roast level distinction standards were passed on to consumers unchanged, it would undoubtedly increase the learning pressure on consumers: "What? So dark roast isn't the darkest?" "I just want to drink coffee that isn't sour, and you're telling me about dark roast, city roast, full city roast—I don't understand either." Indeed, some terms cannot be understood at all without deeper knowledge. If labeled this way, it would increase consumer confusion.


烘焙度对照1


If we don't distinguish according to this, and instead understand and differentiate what is a light roast and what is a dark roast based on each shop's roast level, then it would be impossible to achieve uniformity. For example, if Shop A's definition of light roast differs from Shop B's definition of light roast, then the light roast labels from these two shops are actually meaningless.


Front Street believes that the simplest way to distinguish roast levels is based on the degree of sourness, sweetness, and bitterness of the coffee, so that consumers can better understand what kind of coffee beans they actually need. Front Street will classify all coffees with sourness as medium-light roast, and coffees mainly bitter as medium-dark roast. In this way, we can determine the coffee's roast level through the flavor description on the coffee label.


图片


For example, if the flavor describes relatively sour fruits like "lemon, citrus, berries," it can be judged as a relatively light coffee bean within the medium-light roast category. If the flavor describes sweeter fruits like "honeydew, grapes, slightly sour fruits," it can be judged as a relatively medium coffee bean within the medium-light roast category. If the flavor describes obviously sweet flavors like "sucrose, maple syrup, chocolate," it can be judged as a relatively medium coffee bean within the medium-dark roast category. If the flavor describes flavors that are bitter with sweetness, such as "nuts, dark chocolate, caramel," it can be judged as a relatively dark coffee bean within the medium-dark roast category.

This also corresponds to the brewing parameters recommended by Front Street: for medium-light roast, use a water temperature of 90-93°C, and a grind size with a 75-80% pass rate through a No. 20 sieve. For more acidic flavors, choose the higher water temperature and finer grind within this range; for sweeter flavors, choose the lower water temperature and coarser grind within this range. For medium-dark roast, use a water temperature of 86-89°C, and a grind size with a 70-75% pass rate through a No. 20 sieve. For more bitter flavors, use the lower water temperature and coarser grind within this range.


水温92度93b


Therefore, Front Street has not failed to write the roast level, but has expressed the roast level of this bean in another form.图片


The above content is compiled by CoffeeHunters, a coffee news website.

You May Also Like