What is a black coffee order and where do store rules end?

On May 11, a woman at a Shenzhen Starbucks asked to take coffee cups from the counter without permission and was stopped by staff. She then threw cups, materials, and a sign at employees, kicked items near the entrance, and was taken away by police after video of the scene spread online.

The dispute raised debate over how stores manage consumables, how staff communicate limits, and where public behavior should stop. For customers ordering a black coffee or a long black, the case is a reminder that counter cups and materials belong to the shop, and that disagreements over store rules are usually settled through staff or management.

Recently, a conflict between a customer and an employee occurred at a Starbucks store in Shenzhen. A woman, after being denied permission to take a coffee cup from the counter, suddenly lost control of her emotions, throwing cups and materials around the store, and even hurling cups and a sign at the staff. Video of the scene quickly sparked discussion after spreading on social media. Some witnesses said the woman also kicked and damaged items at the entrance and cursed at people in English and Cantonese, and was eventually taken away by police who responded to the call. Netizens hold differing views on the store's rules for managing consumables, the way customers are communicated with, and the boundaries of behavior in public places. This article compiles the course of the incident and voices from various sides, along with some reflections on the daily operations of coffee shops.

▲

Click to follow | Daily specialty coffee culture magazine Coffee Works

Recently, several videos recording a woman having an emotional outburst and throwing things around inside a coffee shop have circulated widely on social media, drawing considerable attention.

On May 11, a netizen uploaded a video filmed at a Starbucks store in Shenzhen. In the footage, a female customer, after arguing with an employee, became extremely agitated, continuously throwing things from inside the store and forcefully hurling them at staff members behind the bar, quickly leaving the floor in a messy state.

From the video, the woman can be seen standing in front of the counter, grabbing materials and coffee cups placed on the tabletop one after another and throwing them around. The sounds of cups colliding with wooden boards and falling to the ground can also be heard in the footage.

During this time, a staff member behind the bar tried to step forward to stop her, but the woman immediately threw items violently in her direction, forcing the employee to retreat and dodge, while another colleague raised an arm to shield her face.

According to witnesses at the scene, the woman had come to this Starbucks to get coffee to go, and wanted to take cups from the tabletop without permission, and the employee stopped her. Afterward, the woman lost her temper at the employee, became increasingly agitated, began randomly throwing materials on the cashier counter, and kept hurling coffee cups at the staff — this was exactly the scene captured in the video circulating online.

Other witnesses added in the comments section that in addition to the frantic cup-throwing seen in the video, the woman also kicked and damaged items at the entrance, threw out the sign (advertising board), "and kept cursing in English and Cantonese."

Netizens who witnessed the incident said that because the troublemaking woman's behavior was so extreme, the flying cups nearly hit passersby, and she cursed at anyone who stepped forward to persuade her, with the whole process lasting quite a long time. Later, someone saw that the situation was going badly and immediately called the police. Just a few minutes after the incident, the woman in black was taken away from the scene by the police who arrived.

Regarding this matter, some netizens believe that if the woman really became so agitated over the coffee cup issue, the employee could simply have handed her one, and it would not have escalated into such a commotion. Other netizens shared their own experiences, mentioning that they had once asked Starbucks staff for plain hot water and were allowed to have it.

In fact, across all chain stores, these cups are consumables; inventory must be counted every month and records must match, and even if they are damaged, they must be reported as loss in the system, so they naturally cannot be given away at will.

More voices pointed out that regardless of whether the employee's refusal to give a cup was appropriate, the woman could have resolved the matter through proper communication or by finding another way, rather than smashing and destroying the store's property. This kind of reckless, extreme behavior is purely venting personal emotions.

Image source: Internet

Disclaimer: Some images in this article are from the Internet. For some content on the website, such as images, we will respect the original author's copyright and indicate the source. However, due to the large volume, a few images and texts may not have been credited in time; please forgive us. If the original author has any disputes, they may contact the website for handling, and once verified, we will correct it immediately. Compiled and edited by "Coffee Works"; please indicate the source when reprinting. If there is any infringement, please inform us for removal. Thank you~!

The above content is compiled by CoffeeHunters, a coffee news website.