Street Coffee Brands and the Manner Canvas Bag Giveaway Failure

Manner ran a one-day collaboration with Shanghai's Power Station of Art: buy two new drinks and receive a Lady Knight canvas tote, limited to 10,000 bags nationwide. Many customers paid successfully, then saw orders automatically canceled, or arrived at stores to find the gifts gone. Some suspected resale of the bags on second-hand platforms. It is not the first time Manner has drawn criticism over gift inventory.

Stores open as early as 7:30, and buyers who paid at 7:31 were told their order had not gone through. Staff blamed a system glitch and pointed customers to headquarters. Office workers who timed mini-program orders to the 10 a.m. opening also lost their bags, even after baristas agreed to hold one. The gap between advertised stock and what street coffee outlets actually held is at the center of the complaints.

Manner has launched a collaboration with the Power Station of Art in Shanghai: buy two of the new drinks and get a "Lady Knight" canvas tote bag. The offer is limited to one day only, with just 10,000 bags available nationwide, sparking a buying frenzy. However, many customers had their orders automatically canceled by the system after successful payment, or were told upon arriving at the store that the gifts were already gone, making for a terrible experience. Netizens questioned whether stores had stocked too few bags, whether the system's inventory matched reality, and some even suspected the gifts were being resold at high prices on second-hand platforms. This is not the first time Manner has been criticized over gift inventory issues, and its brand reputation has taken another hit. Front Street Coffee is following this story and walks you through what happened.

This story starts two days ago. Manner's official account released news of its latest collaboration, announcing a partnership with the Power Station of Art: customers who buy two of the new coffees get a "Lady Knight" co-branded canvas tote bag, and the perk is valid today only. As soon as the news dropped, merch hunters set their alarms last night for this morning, planning to grab the bag the moment it went live.

It's understood that some Manner stores open as early as 7:30. Some quick-acting customers completed payment at 7:31 on the dot, and with the order showing payment successful, they rushed straight to the store—only to learn from staff that the order hadn't actually gone through and the tote bags were already gone. When customers showed their payment receipts, staff explained it was a system glitch and suggested calling headquarters to sort it out; in reality, the order had already been canceled.

"Payment successful—order canceled—sold out," and "Good news: I got it! Bad news: it was canceled"—that's how netizens who failed to grab a bag described their emotional rollercoaster.

Besides the go-getters who got up early only to come away empty-handed, another group—office workers—targeted the store closest to them that had the gift, timing their mini-program order for the 10 a.m. opening. Some called the store's barista after ordering to ask them to hold a bag, and the barista agreed. But before they even arrived, they were told the gifts were gone, and their order was automatically refunded soon after.

It's said that Manner's promotional poster states the co-branded canvas tote bags are limited to 10,000 units, available while supplies last. That means the stock allocated to stores nationwide was pitifully small, and getting one came down to sheer speed. As for this tote bag's inventory, a netizen revealed that a Manner employee said each store only stocked 10 bags—5 for online and 5 for in-store—and that the inventory shown in the mini-program was subject to actual store conditions.

When actually ordering, because the number of gifts is limited, if multiple people order at the same time, the system confirms orders by whoever paid first and directly cancels the rest. But if a store's inventory settings don't match the actual remaining quantity, then even after all the tote bags are gone, the mini-program will still show the gift-included set as available. That's how you get situations where people are told there's no stock only after paying, orders are automatically canceled, or customers arrive at the store to be told it was oversold and there's no bag, leaving them to cancel the order themselves.

In response, people have been posting on social platforms to complain that Manner's event planning was absurd and the ordering experience was awful. If you advertise a free gift in advance, you should stock enough inventory—not let people pay, happily think their order went through, and then be told there's no stock, getting excited over nothing.

"Manner's hunger marketing has gone too far this time," "This collaboration really ruins goodwill," "If the brand can't afford it, why hold the event at all?" "Whose co-branded gift runs out at 7:30 in the morning?" "If you're not sincere, don't run a promotion!"... As for who exactly this impossibly hard-to-get tote bag was sold to, a netizen said in the comments, "Turns out they all ended up on a second-hand platform, being sold at high prices."

Looking back at co-branded promotions in recent years, this is not the first time Manner has been criticized for stocking too few gifts. Now, with the "automatic order cancellation" issue, it's been branded with labels like "hunger marketing," and goodwill among many fans has dropped sharply. It seems that in today's coffee race, Manner still has a long way to go if it wants to secure a place.

Image source: Internet

Disclaimer: Some images in this article come from the internet. For some content on the website, such as images, we will respect the original creator's copyright and cite the source. However, due to the sheer volume, a few images and texts may not have been credited in time; we ask for your understanding. If the original creator has any dispute, please contact the website and we will handle it. Once verified, we will correct it immediately. Compiled and edited by "Coffee Workshop"; please indicate the source when reposting. If there is any infringement, please let us know and we will delete it. Thank you~!

The above content is compiled by CoffeeHunters, a coffee news website.